Friday, October 30 2026

What Are the Dhanasar Prongs, and What Evidence Does Each One Need?

The Dhanasar three-prong test is the standard USCIS applies to decide whether to waive the job offer in an EB-2 petition. Your proposed endeavor must have substantial merit and national importance; you must be well positioned to advance it; and, on balance, waiving the job offer and labor certification must benefit the United States. All three have to be met, each by a preponderance of the evidence.

Most explanations stop there. This one sets out, for each prong, the question an officer is answering and the documents that answer it, and closes with an evidence map for your own file.

Where does the Dhanasar test come from?

From a precedent decision of USCIS's Administrative Appeals Office: **Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016)*, decided December 27, 2016. It vacated the framework set in 1998 by Matter of New York State Dep't of Transp. (NYSDOT*), 22 I&N Dec. 215.

The reason for the change explains what the current test avoids. The AAO wrote that NYSDOT's third prong had generated "the greatest confusion for petitioners and adjudicators", partly because it could be read to require "evidence relevant to the very labor market test that the waiver is intended to forego," and that it had "proven particularly ill-suited for USCIS to evaluate petitions from self-employed individuals, such as entrepreneurs."

Two points place the test in the process:

●       It comes second. The EB-2 NIW criteria have two layers. First you must qualify for the EB-2 classification, as an advanced degree professional or a person of exceptional ability. The USCIS Policy Manual is direct: "If the person does not have the qualifications for the EB-2 classification, the petition is statutorily ineligible for the national interest waiver." Our guide to EB-2 NIW requirements in 2026 covers that threshold.

●       Meeting it opens discretion, not an entitlement. In Dhanasar's words: "If these three elements are satisfied, USCIS may approve the national interest waiver as a matter of discretion."

Today the framework is applied through the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Section D, which restates the prongs and adds examples. How that guidance has been revised is covered in What Did the January 2025 USCIS Policy Update Change for EB-2 NIW?

What are the three Dhanasar prongs, and do you have to meet all three?

There are three, and a petition has to meet all three. Under Dhanasar, USCIS may grant the waiver if the petitioner demonstrates:

"(1) that the foreign national's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; (2) that the foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and (3) that, on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification."

The prongs are cumulative, not a scorecard where a strong prong offsets a weak one. The Policy Manual describes a sequence: "Once officers have determined that the petitioner met the first two prongs, they proceed with the analysis of the third prong."

Each prong looks at something different. Prong 1 is about the work. Prong 2 is about you: "Unlike the first prong, which focuses on the merit and importance of the proposed endeavor, the second prong centers on the person." Prong 3 weighs the two together.

Dhanasar itself shows what "cumulative" means. The petitioner proposed hypersonic propulsion research and STEM teaching. The research cleared all three prongs. The teaching did not clear the first — the record did not show activities "that would impact the field of STEM education more broadly" — so the AAO wrote: "we do not address the remaining prongs in relation to the petitioner's teaching activities."

The lesson: a component that fails Prong 1 is not weighed further. It adds length, not support — which is why a petition built around one well-defined endeavor generally reads more clearly than one bundling a strong core with side activities.

What does "preponderance of the evidence" mean in an NIW petition?

It means each element of the petition, including each of the three Dhanasar prongs, has to be shown to be probably true. Dhanasar states the standard in a footnote, citing Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010):

"Under the 'preponderance of the evidence' standard, a petitioner must establish that he or she more likely than not satisfies the qualifying elements. … We will consider not only the quantity, but also the quality (including relevance, probative value, and credibility) of the evidence."

The USCIS Policy Manual (Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4) adds that "even if there is some doubt," relevant, probative and credible evidence that leads an officer to believe a claim is "probably true" or "more likely than not" satisfies the standard. Its footnote ties "more likely than not" to INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca: a greater than 50 percent probability.

That is a lower bar than certainty. It is also easy to misread in four ways:

●       The burden stays with you. In the Policy Manual's words: "The burden of proof never shifts to USCIS."

●       It is not a volume contest. Chawathe, quoting an earlier decision: "[t]ruth is to be determined not by the quantity of evidence alone but by its quality."

●       It does not waive the regulations. Per Chawathe, the standard "does not relieve the petitioner or applicant from satisfying the basic evidentiary requirements set by regulation." For the waiver, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(ii) requires "evidence to support the claim that such exemption would be in the national interest."

●       It is not about whether your venture will succeed. What must be probably true is each element, such as that you are well positioned. Dhanasar: "We do not, therefore, require petitioners to demonstrate that their endeavors are more likely than not to ultimately succeed."

The practical consequence is in how evidence is read. Chawathe says each piece is examined "for relevance, probative value, and credibility, both individually and within the context of the totality of the evidence." When the standard is not met, the Policy Manual says "it is appropriate for the officer to either request additional evidence or issue a notice of intent to deny, or deny the case." A claim moves from asserted to probably true when a document an officer can check stands behind it.

Prong 1: What evidence proves substantial merit and national importance?

Evidence that defines one specific endeavor and shows its effects reaching beyond a single employer or client, ideally through sources with no stake in your petition. The first Dhanasar prong asks:

"the foreign national's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance"

What it means. Two tests. Merit is broad: it "may be demonstrated in a range of areas such as business, entrepreneurialism, science, technology, culture, health, or education," and "may be established without immediate or quantifiable economic impact." National importance is narrower. Dhanasar looks at the endeavor's "potential prospective impact": "we do not evaluate prospective impact solely in geographic terms. Instead, we look for broader implications." The Policy Manual frames the question as "whether the petitioner can demonstrate that the person's own individual endeavor stands to have broader implications, such as for a field, a region, or the public at large."

What it implies. The prong is about the endeavor, not your profession or your industry. As of October 2026, the Policy Manual says the analysis "focuses on what the person will be doing rather than the specific job title or occupational classification," and it names several arguments as insufficient on their own — a national shortage in your occupation, benefits to a single employer, the general importance of teaching or entrepreneurship. Our article on the January 2025 update walks through those examples.

The questions Prong 1 asks, and what answers each:

●       What, exactly, is the endeavor? Your endeavor description. USCIS asks it to "describe the specific projects and goals" rather than "simply listing the duties and responsibilities" of the occupation, and to "clearly lay out the potential direct impacts of the endeavor and whether the endeavor will be furthered through the course of the person's duties at a particular employer or some other way."

●       Does the work have merit? Material documenting the problem the endeavor addresses: government reports, agency strategies, published research, sector data from sources with no stake in your petition.

●       Do its effects reach beyond one employer or client? Most of the evidentiary work lies here. The Policy Manual's examples point to "widespread interest in adoption or licensing of the technology, a novel and important manufacturing or operational process, or how the technology stands to impact the development of similar technology by other companies"; to "prospective public health benefits"; or to job creation "at a level that is significant with respect to the population and economic circumstances of the relevant region."

●       Does anyone outside your circle recognize that importance? In Dhanasar, the record included "probative expert letters from individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry" and "media articles and other evidence documenting the interest of the House Committee on Armed Services in the development of hypersonic technologies." The Policy Manual adds that letters from interested government agencies, though not required, "can be relevant to all three prongs."

Notice the move: the record did not argue that hypersonics matter in general. It tied the specific research to documented U.S. strategic interest, through senior experts and evidence of congressional interest.

Prong 2: How is "well positioned" different from being qualified?

Being qualified is the EB-2 threshold: a degree, or exceptional ability. Being well positioned, the second Dhanasar prong, is the connection between you and this particular endeavor. The prong asks:

"the foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor"

What it means. As of October 2026, the Policy Manual draws the line: "A degree in and of itself, however, is not a sufficient basis to determine that a person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor." And it names the scale that matters: "the more integral a person is to an endeavor, the stronger the case the person presents that they are well-positioned to advance the endeavor."

USCIS illustrates the gap: someone whose banking experience is "limited to working as a teller or accounts manager" may not be well positioned to launch a consulting business advising U.S. banks nationally. The experience is real; its connection to the endeavor is not established.

What it implies. The evidence has to show fit and momentum, not just credentials. The Policy Manual lists four factors, and each maps to its own kind of document:

1.    Education, skills, knowledge and record of success in related or similar efforts. Degrees and licenses; publications and "a strong citation history"; patents; evidence that your work "has influenced the field of endeavor"; and evidence of "how the person's work is being used by others," such as contracts or licenses.

2.    A detailed plan you developed, or played a significant role in developing. A plan for continuing the work in the United States, or a business plan where the endeavor is entrepreneurial. Plans "should be supported by other independent evidence" — covered in detail in our January 2025 update article.

3.    Progress toward the endeavor. Contracts and agreements, an entity with your role documented, pilots, revenue or jobs created with your contribution shown.

4.    Interest or support garnered from others. Correspondence from prospective customers, users or investors; investment from U.S. investors in amounts "appropriate to the relevant endeavor"; grants and awards; admission to an incubator or accelerator; letters from government agencies.

The Policy Manual repeats Dhanasar's point that you need not show the endeavor will probably succeed, and adds the constraint: "However, unsubstantiated claims would not meet the petitioner's burden of proof." The evidence list is "not meant to be a checklist": covering every item is neither required nor sufficient. What matters is that your documents point at this endeavor.

Prong 3: What evidence supports the "on balance" argument?

Mostly the record built for the first two prongs, plus documents on the factors USCIS weighs: impracticality of a labor certification, benefit even if U.S. workers are available, urgency, and economic impact. The third Dhanasar prong asks whether:

"on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification"

What it means. A weighing. On one side is the purpose of labor certification, which the Policy Manual, as of October 2026, describes as ensuring that "the admission of foreign workers will not adversely affect the job opportunities, wages, and working conditions of U.S. workers." On the other, the benefit of proceeding without it. Per Dhanasar, unlike NYSDOT, this prong "does not require a showing of harm to the national interest or a comparison against U.S. workers in the petitioner's field." One argument is ruled out: "evidence of a national labor shortage in the person's occupation would not, by itself, satisfy this third prong."

What it implies. The officer assesses whether "the person's endeavor and the person being well-positioned to advance that endeavor, taken together" outweigh the benefits of labor certification. A thin record on the first two prongs leaves little to weigh.

The factors, and what answers each:

●       Impracticality of a labor certification, given your qualifications or endeavor: documents showing how the endeavor is structured — self-employment, ownership of the entity, a role a standard job posting could not describe. For someone self-employed in a way that generally does not affect U.S. workers adversely, the Policy Manual notes "there may be little benefit from the labor certification."

●       Benefit even if U.S. workers are available: the Prong 1 and Prong 2 record, read together. That is how Dhanasar concluded: the petitioner "offers contributions of such value that, on balance, they would benefit the United States even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available."

●       Urgency, "such as a time-sensitive public health or safety benefit": documentation of the need itself, not an assertion of it. Government agency letters can help "by explaining a particular urgency."

●       Economic impact and job creation: figures, with their source.

For STEM endeavors, USCIS treats one combination as "a strong positive factor" here — an advanced STEM degree, especially a Ph.D., work furthering a critical and emerging technology or another STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness, and being well positioned to advance it. A combination, not a credential.

What do strong documents have in common across all three prongs?

Which documents weigh most is a question of its own. What the texts quoted here reward across all three Dhanasar prongs is simpler: evidence that is independent, verifiable and quantified.

Independent. The Policy Manual describes outside investment and government grants as evidence that "may provide independent validation," and treats letters as persuasive when "supported by other independent evidence." Chawathe shows the distinction at work: it called an SEC filing based on audited financial statements "highly credible," while noting that a specific claim in the employer's letter was "not supported by independent evidence." The letter still counted: it was relevant, uncontroverted and generally supported by the filing. A useful way to sort your file is into three types:

●       Independent — from a party with no stake in your petition: a government agency, an unaffiliated expert, an investor, the press.

●       Affiliated — from someone connected to you: your employer, a co-author, your own company.

●       Self-generated — your statement, your plan, your CV.

Affiliated and self-generated documents are not useless: they explain and organize. Independent documents corroborate.

Verifiable. A document is stronger when it points to something an officer can check: a grant number, a signed contract, a patent, a publication, a filing. The Policy Manual says it plainly in its guidance on entrepreneurs: "Claims lacking corroborating evidence are not sufficient to meet the petitioner's burden of proof."

Quantified. For entrepreneurial endeavors, USCIS "would also welcome probative evidence to support how the person has anticipated relevant metrics such as market size and share, job creation, and revenue growth," and acknowledges that beyond revenue or valuation, "other metrics may be of equal importance." Outside business the same holds: citations are one metric, and users, adoption and cost savings are others.

Why can one inconsistency weaken all three prongs?

Because the three Dhanasar prongs share their facts. The endeavor description defines Prong 1. Your track record supports Prong 2 only in relation to that endeavor. Prong 3 weighs both. A contradiction in one place travels.

Take an endeavor statement describing supply-chain analytics for regional hospitals, a CV showing the last five years in retail pricing, and letters praising "outstanding data skills" without naming either. Each document might be fine alone. Together they leave an officer unsure what the endeavor is, whether you are positioned for it, and what is being weighed. Chawathe describes evidence read "individually and within the context of the totality of the evidence"; a doubt raised in one document does not stay there.

A final consistency read, done across documents rather than within each one, is generally among the most useful things you can do to a file before filing.

How do you map your own evidence to each prong?

List every document you have. Assign each to a prong and to the question it answers, label it independent, affiliated or self-generated, and look for gaps.

USCIS's own filing tips shape this exercise: "There is no single factor or piece of evidence that will establish eligibility," and "a petition organized around the issues below and in that order should assist adjudicators to more easily identify relevant information and evidence pertaining to the various aspects of the adjudication." That order is EB-2 eligibility first, then Prongs 1, 2 and 3.

Prong 1 — the work

●       Could someone else in your occupation sign your endeavor description unchanged? If so, it describes a profession, not an endeavor.

●       Which independent source documents the problem your endeavor addresses?

●       What shows impact beyond your employer or clients: adoption, licensing, public benefit, regional jobs?

●       What's missing for this prong? ______

Prong 2 — you

●       Which past results relate directly to this endeavor, rather than to your field in general?

●       Is there a plan you developed, and does something outside the plan support its numbers?

●       What progress can you document today: contracts, pilots, an entity, users?

●       Which third parties have shown interest or support, in writing?

●       What's missing for this prong? ______

Prong 3 — the balance

●       Why would a labor certification be impractical for this endeavor, or why does the benefit hold even if U.S. workers are available?

●       If you claim urgency, what documents the time-sensitive need?

●       Are job-creation or economic-impact figures sourced?

●       What's missing for this prong? ______

Across all three

●       Do the endeavor, dates and titles read the same in your statement, CV, letters and plan?

●       Does every figure appear identically wherever it appears?

●       Does each letter refer to something documented elsewhere in the file?

●       For each prong, how many items are independent, and how many self-generated?

The map is an organizer, not a score. It shows where a file is thin; it does not predict how any petition will be decided.

Where can you read the Dhanasar framework yourself?

Every source quoted here is public: Matter of Dhanasar and Matter of Chawathe; the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 (the prongs) and Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 4 (standards of proof); 8 CFR 204.5(k); and USCIS's Employment-Based Immigration: Second Preference EB-2 page, with its National Interest Waiver Filing Tips.

The Policy Manual passages quoted were current as of October 2026; the Manual is updated over time, so it is worth rechecking the chapter before filing. Questions about a denial or an appeal are legal questions, and an immigration attorney is the right person to answer them.

At DAL Global Partners, we prepare the documentation that fills this map: endeavor statements that describe specific work, expert letters built on first-hand knowledge and tied to evidence already in the record, and business plans whose figures are anchored rather than asserted. If your map has gaps, you can request our services. The adjudication standard is not ours to control. The precision and coherence of the file is.

 

Disclaimer: This post is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or a recommendation regarding any specific immigration matter.